I’ve spent quite a bit of time looking for a new theme for Nfaf (or an old one I can manipulate) and I must say that I’m starting to get discouraged with the process. I’m cheap, first of all, so whatever I get has to be free. Secondly, I’m your typical obnoxious editor — I have a greater idea of style than the ability to execute. In other words, I can tell you something looks ugly, but I can’t make it pretty. Third, I’m demanding. I want a theme to use the features of WP I’m interested in, in the way I want them used, and not give me all that other garbage.
For instance, one of the things I really like about this theme (and the Qwilm! theme it’s based on — didn’t remember that until I saw Bill’s new look) is the fact that it doesn’t have a big framing border across the top.
Now, I understand headers are useful. They can help serve to anchor the user in the space, they can hold lots of useful information, and they give you an opportunity to set the tone of your blog.
However, all blogs tend to look alike, whether or not they’re using the same underlying theme (or even blogging engine). Blog design is already like car design — so standardized that people can’t tell one make/model from another except for looking at the little details.
Perhaps this is a function of function. Most websites exist to share information with other people, with text being the most common method. We’re already used to reading text from books, newspapers, pamphlets and magazines… these all have a pretty well-defined paradigm and are easily transferred to the web-as-it-is (except for decent typography). And heaven knows that we’re all pretty much used to writing text (with varying skill levels, to be sure).
But have we reached the limits of web presentation? Just refining this point and that one (choosing cloth seats over leather, or metallic blue instead of silver paint), forever repainting the walls without moving them?
Maybe I’m obsessing too much about this. I mean, I don’t have a lot of readers, and most of them come through RSS anyway. And I am a great believer in content over presentation — but to be honest, I have clicked off of sites that could have been the absolute best for whatever topic I was trying to learn about because they were ugly. For a subjective value of ugly, of course.
So now I’m thinking, why bother with a new theme at all? Well, I don’t know. Is “because I can” a good enough reason?